Sorry to hear about the accident... Similarly some numbskull hit me only 5-6 months after I bought my Jeep. On the bright side the compensation I received from my insurance is what bought me my front bumper
You'll probably be happy regardless of which bumper you go with. Have you looked at the Rugged Ridge XHD modular front bumper? You can configure it in several different ways so much so that it comes out looking like either the body armor or smittybilt one. It's a little more expensive depending on how you configure it but it looks a little meaner and better than the above two IMO.
2003 Patriot Blue Wrangler SE - RCX 2.5" Kit on 31x10.5 Firestone M/Ts and stock the rest of the way.
2007 Flame Red Wrangler Unlimited X - Skyjacker 4" Kit on 35x12.5 Cooper Discovery STT(My Build Details