So I finally got the axle torn down. The passenger seal was definitely egg shaped - my fault when I did the ball joints.
My question now is whether it is possible to install the seals too deep as there really isn't a shoulder for it to bottom out on. I think I have them a little deeper than the stock ones. There is plenty of turned area on the shaft so I hope it is OK. I would hate to have them leak again.
2007 JK 2dr Rubicon, 3" Black Diamond Lift, 35" KM2s, M/T Classic IIs, Rancho shocks, Mopar bumpers, 8000 lb winch, Ace rock sliders, Skid Row engine/oil pan skid, evap skid, Tom Woods driveshafts, Riddler diff covers, rear adjustable upper control arms, chromoly rear shafts, Reid knuckles, Synergy chromoly tie rod, track bar, and flipped drag link.