If you're willing to cut fenders, you can fit 35s under there, maybe with rubbing at full lock (especially rubbing with stock wheels). I did that with 315/75/16 KM2s on 4.25in backspacing wheels. Great tires, btw, regardless of what size you get. I'd go with 33s-ish.
Like Jeepveda, I have the Rugged Ridge XHD, but with the Pre-Runner Guard. I had two quality defects with the short base, and the pre-runner guard had a bent light mount, and has already started to get some surface rust (maybe in part to blame on the Michigan salt). So, I've been looking elsewhere (Poison Spyder, actually, again, like Jeepveda mentioned) for a rear bumper/tire carrier.
I have the WARN 9.5ti. I love it, but haven't used it for anything to serious yet. I understand that the M8000 (I think that's it), is also a quality Warn winch, and should also be enough for a 2dr, imo.
08 Jeep Green JKU Sahara - OME 2'' Heavy Duty Lift (1'' spacers in front), 35'' BFG KM2s on Black 16'' wheels, Cut Fenders, Rugged Ridge Bumper w/ Pre-Runner Guard, WARN 9.5ti winch, PSC RockBrawler Rear Bumper+Tire Carrier, Smittybilt SRC Rock Rails, Hella Auxiliary Lights