2 months on Bestop Supertop NX twill
Biggest mistake I ever made was buying the hardtop for my 2012 Jk 2 door, the heat doesn't bother me so as long as its above 65 or so i run with the top off no matter how hot it gets.
The problem here in Houston is it can rain at any time out of a clear sky, and there are no good options to keep you that dry.
I also didn't like the freedom top design, it sounds good on paper, but I found that since there is no way to open the back window on the hardtop while driving it would create a vortex of air at 50 mph or higher that made my eardrums feel like they were going to burst. I know that might be just me, but it was pretty intensely painful every time I tried it.
In my opinion it also scratches way to easy. The paint is just way to thin.
But enough about that
So I decided to go with the new bestop supertop NX in Twill and ditch the hardtop.
First, whoever wrote the instructions hates you... passionately. An hour in and you will want to track them down and murder their entire bloodline so they cant continue to pollute the earth.
The you tube video is a better show on how to do it, once I watched that video, I ditched the instructions and had it on in about 30 minutes.
Everyone says it should be in the 70's to install it, but it was in the 50's and I had no real issues, but I am a big boy so I could manhandle it a little bit.
The secret is to attach the brackets to the sports bars and then all the bows before messing with the fabric.
Once it was on I loved it. It is BLACK, just drinks in the light.
It has a nice sturdy feel to the fabric, and is pretty easy to take down and put back up once you get the hang of it. I highly recommend the window bag bestop sells. I know people complain about the price, but its so damn convenient for rolling up the windows.
I like the sunrider feature alot more than I expected I would. But I do find the cross beam distracting, cant have everything I suppose. I know alot of people run without it, but I find that the top is considerably louder if you don't have it.
You will hear people complain about a whistling sound with these tops. What I found was when you put the top up sometimes the seal on the header on the front windshield gets pinched and that will cause the whistling above 30mph. Just push it back into place with your finger and its good to go
Oddly I find the noise level about the same on the hardtop or the softtop, the softtop may actually be a little quieter. Its also strangely more watertight. It definetly doesn't insulate as well as the hardtop, I can tell that is a little colder
The only real negative is as good as that blacker than black top looks clean, every single speck of dirt and mud shine like the sun. Some people have complained about the mud staining the black, i have gotten mine pretty muddy and haven't had any staining, but the mud in southeast Texas may be different from where they live.
We will have to see how it holds up after a year, but outside of my enduring rage about the poor instructions I couldn't be happier. Mine didn't come with the elastic garters that hold up the back window, but I called bestop and they overnight ed them right to me. They also advised me about 4 times not to use traditional top cleaners and sealers you would use for a canvas or vinyl top, and that if I take it to the carwash to be careful not to let them, they seemed sort of serious about it so I would assume there is some sort of problem there. They said they would have a line of products out for this top in a month or so.