I had the OEM sailcloth on mine for years until it started coming apart. I replaced mine with a quadratec replace a top softop. It comes with a 3yr warranty so it's another reason I went with it. It's not a sailcloth however it's a tight fit so it's actually not real noisy. I chose not to get a sailcloth because I run a hardtop in the colder months and in the summer months I have the top down more than I have it up. Plus I didn't want to mess a $600 top up on a trail ride. If it was my only top, I might have gone with a sailcloth. But the quadratec top so far has been a great top. The zippers are same quality as OEM, I had to pinch the zippers a little tighter because I was having issues when it zipped in certain sections it wouldn't zip and had a hole where it should have zipped. Easy fix by adjusting the zip tighter.
Talk to the rep on here from quadratec. He gave me a nice deal on a full top with tinted windows and front uppers for a great price.
Yellow Jeep Member #42
01 Jeep TJ, HP 30/Locked, dana44/locked, 4.88's, 4in SA lift, JKS 1.25 bl, JKS Trackbar, 35x12.50 MTR Kevlars, 15x8 Soft 8's, Hella Foglights w/windshield mount, Skyjacker Discos, Cobra cb, Brown Dog MML, SYE, Smittybilt Rear Bumper/Tire Carrier, Currie Steering, Warn x8000i
03 Jeep TJ, 1 Ton Project. 79 Dana 60/dana 70, 5.9L 360, hiline tube fenders