I just got a new tank, skid plate and all three straps. The straps from quadratec aren't that expensive, so you might get new ones. I looked at my old ones and they were all beat up and unusable. You might luck out, but all in all it may be a better idea to go with new ones. The kit for a 76 CJ was like 49 bucks for all three straps. I also got the new sending unit as well. I went all new and together for the
was like $325 with the shipping. I don't know what your budget is, but I definitely agree with the motto of doing it once and doing it right. If it is in question, probably better to replace it.