So, quick update:
I used Gorilla Glue last night, after sanding with 200 grit sand paper, and cleaning the windshield with rubbing alcohol. Went to mount the mirror this morning, and lo and behold, it stayed up just fine!!! However, now, it would appear as if the fiancee's cat decided the screw that goes into the base would be a fun toy, and it's God knows where in the house now. Luckily, it's a part that can be ordered through Chrysler for $3.60. I'm sure I could also just head over to the hardware store and find a replacement. The issues with this damn mirror have become almost comical at this point, but I'm happy to say that I think all will be well once I get the replacement screw in.
Moral of the story? Windshield adhesive kits don't seem to work great on the OA material, but your standard run of the mill Loctite or Gorilla Glue super glues seem to work great. Again, to reiterate, I'm incredibly happy with the product, and would do business with OA again!
'14 JKU Rubicon
MetalCloak 3.5" Game-Changer 6Pak Edition, Overlines, ExoSkins
Poison Spyder Brawler Lite w/ Trail Stinger
Savegres w/ 315/70R17 Duratracs and 4.88s
'13 WK2 Overland