Sorry you're so unhappy with it, personally I couldn't be happier, and have had zero problems. Actually scratch that, the only problem I had was the foam roller falling apart towards the end and leaving pieces of foam in the liner. I couldn't care less about that though, the liner gets used, and who cares if there is a couple pieces of foam. It's a trail rig, not a frame up restoration.
I've found it to be super, super durable. Hell, the first thing I do when someone looks inside and asks me about it pull out my pocket knife and stab it and whack on it. Their eyes always get wide when they see that and want to know more.
I've even hit it with a map torch in an inconspicuous place out of curiosity, and all it did was discolor.
Looking for: 03-06 interior plastic trim. PM me.