If I could have gotten the MOPAR rubber mats with a taller lip to catch the snow/water, I would have been all over them! I live in New England, snow, ice, water are a real concern.
I went for the WeatherTech variety for this very reason. Though, I would have preferred a heavy RUBBER material to the plastic material of the WeatherTech. Rubber just feels more durable and appropriate underfoot than plastic.
The liners I had in my old Jeep would hold a TON of water (mandatory) - but just bit of a challenge to remove the liner (to dump) without spilling the water on the carpets.