Ended up going w the Pirelli Scorpion Verde All Season, 235/60R18. Had the back put on the other day and the fronts on today. What I thought was a unique, and therefore cool, 70th anniversary edition rim ended up being what has made this such a PITA for me. When I bought this KK I didn't think about the wheel size being 18s. When I looked at the wheels I ASSUMED (I know, I know) that they were 17s. Only reason that I'm not trying to swap out rums is that I might try to sell it soon for a 4x4 and figure keeping the whole 70th Anniversary package together will help.
Thanks for all the advise, as always folks!
2011 Liberty Limited 70th Anniversary Edition