So I decided to go the Plastidip route for no other reason than unbridled curiosity. Didn't actually get to the fog lights yesterday though.
However, I did manage to do my door handles. First impression... Massive improvement! I like the look of the stuff better than I like Rustoleum, and it feels just as sturdy. Only time will tell me otherwise.
Peeling and faded driver's door handle, half masked
Make sure that you get a good line on your masking tape. This appeared to be the vital part of not only getting a clean line, but also making sure that it wouldn't peel off down the road. Take your time and only do it once, or be lazy and do it more than once.
Honestly I think I masked off more than I needed to. Everybody states that you can just peel the excess away once it dries. But it only took me 30 extra seconds to throw the newspaper up there.
Driver's side all finished
Close up of the texture
Honestly it only cost me 5 bucks and two hrs while I waited 15-30 minutes for each new coat. But I think it's the secks.