Price: $0.01
Pros: Good top, came installed on Jeep when bought it. Easy to remove, no additional hardware.
Cons: Sags, flaps on the sides, and has been a pain to clean (probably because the last owner never did).
Recommended? Yes

Comments: It is obviously old, so I cannot hold any cons against Bestop.

Price: $200.00
Pros: Reaplace a tops windows fit great with my oem top, i kept the replace a top as a spare incase something happens on the trail. Best part no more clear windows!!!
Cons: The damn best top sticker that comes on the back window is less than fun to take off
Recommended? Yes

Comments: Reaplace a tops windows fit great with my oem top, i kept the replace a top as a spare incase something happens on the trail. Best part no more clear windows!!!

Price: $500.00
Pros: great replacement
Cons: n/a
Recommended? Yes

Comments: great quality, and awesome fabric. Very easy to install and looks great!! Last longer than the original soft top!!

Price: $499.00
Pros: Easy to Install, looks great. Quieter than factory top in my opinion. Rear corner plastic is segmented so you wont have the notorious issue with the corners wanting to pull out near the rear window.
Cons: I'm not a big fan of the 1/2 door skins being held on with Velcro.
Recommended? Yes

Comments: I couldn't wait a few more months til it got above 70 degrees outside to do the install. So I decided to let the top get to room temperature inside the house and brought it out when it was time to install it (28 Degrees). The install was flawless.
The windows and fabric don't seem as thick as the factory material. But then again I've never had a jeep with a brand new factory top, so the old OEM material may of only seemed thicker due to old age.
I do have an issue with the 1/2 door on the driverside wherethe seal in the rear upper corner doesn't want to line up with the surround. But it appears to be an easy to fix issue where I can readjust the velcro and/or use heat to mold the seal.

Price: $800.00
Pros: tinted, compact
Cons: hard to maintain
Recommended? Yes

Comments: i hate the maintenance on it

Price: $450.00
Pros: Looks great, fits well, love the tinted rear windows, they keep the heat down a little bit.
Cons: None yet
Recommended? Yes

Comments: Top fits nicely, looks good, seems to fit like factory.

Price: $440.00
Pros: Fit Great
Cons: Only available in Black from Quadratec
Recommended? Yes

Comments: I have a hard top and wanted a soft top as well. I purchased all OEM frame hardware and oredered a Replace a Top. If fits and looks great. Install was simple and no leaks of any kind. I would most def purchase again.

Price: $450.00
Recommended? Yes

Comments: has a great fit and vey east to install. i would recommend this as a good replacement once your factory top has worn out.

Price: $520.00
Recommended? Yes

Comments: finally a new top. i think any top would have satisfied me. but i love the tinted windows that keep alot of heat out and it looks fantastic.

Recommended? Yes

Comments: For the OEM top on my '98, it's in pretty good condition. No rips, tears, cracks, etc. after 10 years of use. The thinner material on these early year tops is a little noisy on the highway, especially if it's a little windy out.

Price: $500.00
Recommended? Yes

Comments: This is a great product. Easy to install and fits just like new. Easy to take on and off. Little pricy though.

Price: $377.98
Recommended? Yes

Comments: The Bestop® Replace-a-top™ is the only replacement top featuring the patented Belt Rail™ attachment system and American fabric specially constructed to stretch for easy installation then return to its original shape for tautness. The Repalce-a-top™ also features factory-spec velcro, thread, and webbing. Plus oversized zippers, DOT approved windows, and a rear attachment system that lets you open your tailgate without having to open your rear window. The Replace-a-top consists of fabric only and fit only factory-original hardware.

Price: $550.00
Recommended? Yes

Comments: went with sail cloth this timee. i like the top, it is a lot quieter than the original.......................................... ..................

Price: $436.00
Pros: Factory look at half the price
Cons: Its good, but cant compare to the Factory Top
Recommended? Yes

Comments: I went with the Denim top over the Sailcloth and with Tinted Windows.
DONT TRY TO PUT ON WHEN IT IS UNDER 70 DEGREES. Very hard to do. Its much easier in warmer weather.
The back window zipper doesnt cooperate. It zips more than halfway then gets stuck. Seems like a design flaw in the way they attach the zipper to the window. It looks like it is mis-aligned. Doesn't fold as nicely as OEM.
Overall, the 2nd best option to replace your old top.(1st being factory)

Price: $460.00
Recommended? Yes

Comments: It's a good fit and easy to install. I've only had it for 3 or 4 years, but it's held up pretty good.

Price: $500.00
Recommended? Yes

Comments: Very good product. Bestop is a reliable manufacturer that has been in the business for a long time. My top has held up for a year now and comes with neat features that my stock '99 did not have.

Price: $500.00
Recommended? Yes

Comments: I've had for 5+ years and no probs. The only down side was the initial install. A little noisier than OEM but, hey its a softtop.

Price: $350.00
Recommended? Yes

Comments: strong

Price: $400.00
Recommended? Yes

Comments: Great fitment, looks great, very easy to install.