JeepForum.com

JeepForum.com (http://www.jeepforum.com/forum/)
-   Electrical, Audio, GPS, & 2-Way Radio (http://www.jeepforum.com/forum/f20/)
-   -   JL audio sucks!!! (http://www.jeepforum.com/forum/f20/jl-audio-sucks-108388/)

orangez 10-01-2004 09:25 PM

JL audio sucks!!!
 
Just Kidding!!! I couldnt think of a title that would get your attention. I'm new here and was just wondering what was up with everyone using JL subs in their consoles, enclosures, etc.. I have looked at about 4 threads and that is the ONLY sub I have seen mentioned. I have nothing against JL subs, I was just curious.

BigWaylon 10-01-2004 09:31 PM

started with a JL Audio...blew it (due to my own stupid mistake)...replaced it with a Rockford Fosgate sub...

one of the main reasons you see JL mentioned is they're one of the few that make a quality 6.5" sub, which easily replaces the factory sub in the center console...RF also happens to make a nice one...

Greg

orangez 10-01-2004 09:35 PM

Ooooooooh. that explains the 6.5 sub, but what about the ppl looking for 8's? Same answer would work I guess. I've never had any JL subs, but the ones I've head sounded pretty good. I just think they look old school I guess. Good speakers though.

BigWaylon 10-01-2004 09:45 PM

dunno, really...these are the only two subs I've ever purchased...

you can modify the factory console to take an 8"...and maybe the JL as smaller cubic feet requirements and/or a shallower mounting depth?

when it's in the center console, the look isn't gonna make much difference...

RF:

http://www.dodgetrucks.org/gallery/data/500/1154sub.jpg


JLA:

http://dodgetrucks.org/photopost/data/169sub5.jpg


Greg

SirGCal 10-02-2004 10:42 AM

BW is right on as usual... :thumbsup: ;)

JL Audio is a very strong brand making both SQ and SPL capable subs. The one problem is their price and availability (they have no certified online retailers for JL).

But, they are not the only game in town either. I use them alot but I also have connections in that area... RF makes a good (though more SPL oriented) sub also. Along with high-end MTX, Boston Acoustics, Memphis, Diamond, Elemental, and a/d/s just to name a few.

Here, the JL comes up alot probably due to the 6" sub mentioned. JL does make the best 6" sub on the market. RF and Kicker also have 6" options if you can find them. Moving up to 8" subs, many of the big players come into view. Basically, you need to get subs to fit your applicaiton. Picking a sub should take at least these variables:
  • How much internal volume will the sub(s) need for the box I want to utilize.
  • What voice coil configuration do I need for my sub(s) to wire them to an amp and what power amp/sub rating am I looking for. (Even more important if you already have the amp in mind...)
  • What kind of sound am I looking for (focused on SQ or SPL).

With those you can choose subs more effectively and be happier with your decision in the end.

phoen1c1an 10-02-2004 02:26 PM

I have a JL audio w7 10" and I loved it, till someone blew it.

baldingo1 10-02-2004 10:13 PM

i guess its just me but i HATE JL

AudioGuru 10-03-2004 07:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by baldingo1
i guess its just me but i HATE JL

You are alone, or deaf. JL is one of the few companies out there that produces subs capable of high SPL while maintaining excellent sound quality. And they're bulletproof, too.

baldingo1 10-05-2004 07:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AudioGuru
You are alone, or deaf. JL is one of the few companies out there that produces subs capable of high SPL while maintaining excellent sound quality. And they're bulletproof, too.

JL sucks, they cant compete with other companys (ex: adire audio, resonant engineering, etc), they charge way more then any other companies, and when it comes down to sq and spl levels JL cant compete, when they are pushed hard they cop out. The JL name sells, but the truth it they havent been on top technology wise since they first released the W6. Ive owned JL before, not for very long though because i couldnt stand listening to them. The sq isnt bad at low volume levels but if you ever feel like turning it up you're -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-= out of luck. I listen to my music extremely loud and i only buy the best, thats why i dont buy JL.

If you want a good woofer look intosome Adire stuff, the shiva is an awesome value woofer, and the Brahma will blow you away. Also look into RE, they make some wicked components

BzJeep 10-05-2004 08:32 PM

Well... a few weeks when I went sub shopping I listened to a wide range of subs and I found the 10" JL W7 to be very nice! My friends use Kicker, MTX and Kenwood and I ended up w/ my Alpine Type-R 10 which I absolutely love. This sub is truly amazing! Paired w/ the Alpine M301 amp (which according to the certificate is 383W) sounds clean and makes for a mini earthquake!

SirGCal 10-06-2004 08:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by baldingo1
JL sucks, they cant compete with other companys (ex: adire audio, resonant engineering, etc), they charge way more then any other companies, and when it comes down to sq and spl levels JL cant compete, when they are pushed hard they cop out. The JL name sells, but the truth it they havent been on top technology wise since they first released the W6. Ive owned JL before, not for very long though because i couldnt stand listening to them. The sq isnt bad at low volume levels but if you ever feel like turning it up you're -=-=-=-=-=-=-=-= out of luck. I listen to my music extremely loud and i only buy the best, thats why i dont buy JL.

If you want a good woofer look intosome Adire stuff, the shiva is an awesome value woofer, and the Brahma will blow you away. Also look into RE, they make some wicked components

yea... ok...

Adire and RE do make some excelent stuff. But by no means is JL crap. And if you're listening to stuff THAT loud, you won't be for long... Extended volumes over 100dB can cause perminant hearing damage.

I can make a pair of 13W7's hit hard enough to make most people sick to their stomach while holding a very respectable SQ curve. No, they arent the best in the world, but neither are the one's you mentioned. Are they better? Depends on your personal preference I guess. But even so, JL does not, by any stretch of the word, suck... It really bugs me when someone takes a personal taste and turns it into a brand slander. I personally don't care for Sony at all, and there are better manufacturers out there, but for the average joe, their equipment is very nice. It doesn't SUCK, but I will never own it as long as another viable option exists. I have similar opinions of quite a few other brands as well but it doesn't mean they suck either...

After-all, being voted #1 Overall Company for five strait years, JL Audio must be putting out something good... They can compete, they do compete, and they win. Adire, RE Audio, JL Audio, Elemental Designs, etc. are all good brands.

baldingo1 10-06-2004 10:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SirGCal
yea... ok...

Adire and RE do make some excelent stuff. But by no means is JL crap. And if you're listening to stuff THAT loud, you won't be for long... Extended volumes over 100dB can cause perminant hearing damage.

I can make a pair of 13W7's hit hard enough to make most people sick to their stomach while holding a very respectable SQ curve. No, they arent the best in the world, but neither are the one's you mentioned. Are they better? Depends on your personal preference I guess. But even so, JL does not, by any stretch of the word, suck... It really bugs me when someone takes a personal taste and turns it into a brand slander. I personally don't care for Sony at all, and there are better manufacturers out there, but for the average joe, their equipment is very nice. It doesn't SUCK, but I will never own it as long as another viable option exists. I have similar opinions of quite a few other brands as well but it doesn't mean they suck either...

After-all, being voted #1 Overall Company for five strait years, JL Audio must be putting out something good... They can compete, they do compete, and they win. Adire, RE Audio, JL Audio, Elemental Designs, etc. are all good brands.

ya, i agree with you that it is my opinion, but it is the opinion of a lot of people. the w7 is a good sounding sub, its by far the best woofer that jl puts out right now, but when a 12 retails for around $700-$800 bucks, and the spl and sq compares to a woofer that will cost you half the price, why would you go with jl? instead of a w7 go with an Image Dynamics ID MAX, that will run you about $400. There are so many better sounding, and so many higher powered components out there that will cost you half the price of jl, i dont know why anyone would buy jl

SirGCal 10-06-2004 12:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by baldingo1
ya, i agree with you that it is my opinion, but it is the opinion of a lot of people. the w7 is a good sounding sub, its by far the best woofer that jl puts out right now, but when a 12 retails for around $700-$800 bucks, and the spl and sq compares to a woofer that will cost you half the price, why would you go with jl? instead of a w7 go with an Image Dynamics ID MAX, that will run you about $400. There are so many better sounding, and so many higher powered components out there that will cost you half the price of jl, i dont know why anyone would buy jl

I guess alot of that depends on how you get your prices.. I don't pay half as much as you listed for JL's... But that's a special circumstance. (I wish I had the same situations on alot of the other brands...)

But, so from your perspective and price access, JL doesn't suck, they are just higher-priced. Understandable responce. For me, RE and ED for example is very hard to obtain right now and I pretty much am stuck with retail costs. So for me JL is the cheap option. Hence my point of view...

I just didn't want anyone to think they were utter crap period from your initial comments. They are expensive (retail), and there are cheaper alternatives out there with similar or better quality for sure. But they are not, by any means, junk...

I ran a few ID MAX a while ago. Not bad but they blew early... Went through three in a comp SQ setup. (design used only 1 in the vehicle) Then I changed to a W7 and changed the amps accordingly and had no further problems. This, however, was a specific instance and ID is not at fault. (tests revieled the chamber to be too tight, even though it was in ID's specs. Falloff was above 35Hz and low distortion kept blowing coils. We could have increased box volume to drop internal resonant frequency or changed subs for a model that worked better in the smaller environment.) I've used alot of ID before and would still recommend them to anyone who asked. Don't think I don't like them because of this simple error. It's all a part of development.

My problem now is availability and price, for me, in my current situation, JL is the winner in both catagories. Obviously, not everyone is in my position and you for example have better prices and availability of other brands. That's cool! They are all champions. Expensive champions some are but they are all quality units none the less..

:thumbsup:


The time now is 01:15 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.