i think the wheels would look great black. seems to complement your ride better, the brushed looks like it clashes with the total theme. im not sure if i would go flat or gloss though, i think a nice satin would be great.
Got to love an ORVIS guy...
IRO 5.5", Front LA & Double Sheer TB, Rear Adj SA and TB, JKS Quick Discos, Bilstein 5125, 265/75/16 Nitto Terra's, Cragar 16x& Soft 8s 4" bs
JCR Stage 2 Sliders, IRO Trans Skid, Carolina Drive shaft, IRO exhaust