The Limiteds had sanded, painted, and cleared body colored cladding on them. It doesn't actually look like cladding at all. I'm sure that's what you're talking about. The TSi's had body colored rough textured plastic cladding on them. I do think it would look pretty unique to have black cladding on a Limited though with black rims. I say go for it.
01 TJ - 4.0L, NV3550, 2" Skyjacker budget boost, Xenon flat flares, LoD front bumper, Tuff Stuff rear bumper, RH4X4 sliders, 33" STT Pros on 15x8s