It looks to be a reverse torx bolt, I was using a 12 point socket. It felt snug when I had it on there, but I guess it is probably my own fault for not using the proper tool. I will be replacing them with new bolts though.
2000 Wrangler TJ yellow- 35's MT/R, 3" Zone lift, Advanced adapters sye kit with Tom Woods driveshaft, Savvy/Currie adjustable rear UCA
1995 Wrangler YJ black- 2.5in lift, 31's - Sold :(
2003 Honda CBR600RR- Full arrow exhaust system
1982 Vespa sport 100- 135cc malossi kit, Leo vince exhaust