sounds fair, not a steal or anything, paid 3500 for our 2000 classic which was spotless about a year and a half ago, engine just blew with 190k (had around 155k on it when we got it)
With what i know now i would have gone with a 99 or older
id keep looking and spend an extra couple hundred more on something with less miles, around the 150K you will nickel and dime yourself to death with all sorts of little crap, ball joints, wheel bearings, tres, brakes, exhaust. With those and our new engine I have spent more on this stupid thing than building up my YJ, not to mention taking up all my spare wrenching time...
"Two roads diverged in a wood and I - I took the one less traveled by, and that has made all the difference. "
94 2.5L 5spd with some stuff