Quick version. Replace-a-top vs Quadratop. Tinted windows vs non tinted windows. Gray vs black.
My top is starting to show its age, The drivers side half door window no longer zips together, I have a couple small tears around the seams in the rest of the top, and am missing 3 snaps . I have no problem with the YJ style factory top and my OEM hardware is still in good shape so I just need the cloth. The top that is on it now is a Bestop and from what I think are date stamps on all of the windows it was manufactured in October of 97, so it has held up very well over the years.
I have found two factory replacement tops. One being the Bestop and the other being the QuadraTop. I am happy with the Bestop I have now and they are Jeeps OEM supplier so I am sure I will get a quality product from them. The QuadraTop says it is a quality product and they go into details on the specs and is $164 cheaper but I am worried about this being a you get what you pay for item.
So any love/hate stories about these two tops. What do people think about tint vs non-tint for the small price difference a tinted window seems like a no brainer but just want to make sure. Does the tint significantly affect outward visibility?
Also what is the best stuff to use to seal up the top to try and keep some of the crap off of a light colored top, I am thinking something like scotchgard.
I like the gray color I have now, but if anyone is good with Photoshop and wants to put a black top on my Jeep it would be much appreciated. Would a black top look okay with the gray interior?