JeepForum.com

JeepForum.com (http://www.jeepforum.com/forum/)
-   Wrangler General Discussion (http://www.jeepforum.com/forum/f176/)
-   -   Advantages of JK over TJ?? (http://www.jeepforum.com/forum/f176/advantages-jk-over-tj-1540039/)

Habber 06-22-2013 08:11 PM

Hi Guys,

I'm just looking for input on the advantages or disadvantages of getting into a used 2 door JK and getting rid of my 2001 TJ 5sp. It will be my second car.

Jeep TJ 2001 4.0 5MT

avatheredjeep 06-22-2013 10:52 PM

more power.
generally more creature comforts- seats are awesome.
more flex with stock suspension.
easier to fit bigger tires.
the lower control arms are a bit longer and more tucked up.
you don't have that low hanging trans skid plate.
I like the stock hard and soft tops that come on the newer JKs with the sun rider feature.

mods are more expensive though.

3X4X4 06-23-2013 12:25 AM

I had a JK and got rid of it for a TJ Rubicon.

Thicker metal
Metal grill
Metal fenders
Metal door handles
More REAL, useable power
Much less water leakage from tops, hard or soft
More and cheaper after market parts that have been further developed for more years
More REAL off road capability
Does not burn oil
Straight six, does not have a mini van motor
Is not a mini van disguised as a Jeep Wrangler
Lighter
Smaller footprint
More maneuverable
Much better looking, looks like a Jeep Wrangler
Less invasive electronics like ABS, VSC that cannot be deactivated regardless of what people say
Drives and feels like a Jeep instead of a car/minivan
Does not have the fat butt JK look

No, it is true, I do not much like JKs and I had one for five years and 88,000 miles, hated it every minute. Oh, and that minivan d---n door/seatbelt awful chime, DING, Freaking DING, DING, FnDing, DING, DING. I can still here it dinging in my nightmares. And those plastic Tupa-bumpers. People kept asking me what year my Liberty was, not good.

J

montero1 06-23-2013 02:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 3X4X4 (Post 15596048)
I had a JK and got rid of it for a TJ Rubicon.

Thicker metal
Metal grill
Metal fenders
Metal door handles
More REAL, useable power
Much less water leakage from tops, hard or soft
More and cheaper after market parts that have been further developed for more years
More REAL off road capability
Does not burn oil
Straight six, does not have a mini van motor
Is not a mini van disguised as a Jeep Wrangler
Lighter
Smaller footprint
More maneuverable
Much better looking, looks like a Jeep Wrangler
Less invasive electronics like ABS, VSC that cannot be deactivated regardless of what people say
Drives and feels like a Jeep instead of a car/minivan
Does not have the fat butt JK look

No, it is true, I do not much like JKs and I had one for five years and 88,000 miles, hated it every minute. Oh, and that minivan d---n door/seatbelt awful chime, DING, Freaking DING, DING, FnDing, DING, DING. I can still here it dinging in my nightmares. And those plastic Tupa-bumpers. People kept asking me what year my Liberty was, not good.

J




*Activate Flame Protection*

Habber 06-23-2013 04:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 3X4X4
I had a JK and got rid of it for a TJ Rubicon.

Thicker metal
Metal grill
Metal fenders
Metal door handles
More REAL, useable power
Much less water leakage from tops, hard or soft
More and cheaper after market parts that have been further developed for more years
More REAL off road capability
Does not burn oil
Straight six, does not have a mini van motor
Is not a mini van disguised as a Jeep Wrangler
Lighter
Smaller footprint
More maneuverable
Much better looking, looks like a Jeep Wrangler
Less invasive electronics like ABS, VSC that cannot be deactivated regardless of what people say
Drives and feels like a Jeep instead of a car/minivan
Does not have the fat butt JK look

No, it is true, I do not much like JKs and I had one for five years and 88,000 miles, hated it every minute. Oh, and that minivan d---n door/seatbelt awful chime, DING, Freaking DING, DING, FnDing, DING, DING. I can still here it dinging in my nightmares. And those plastic Tupa-bumpers. People kept asking me what year my Liberty was, not good.

J

You made me laugh on your analysis. Thanks.

Jeep TJ 2001 4.0 5MT

3X4X4 06-23-2013 10:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Habber (Post 15596251)
You made me laugh on your analysis. Thanks.

Jeep TJ 2001 4.0 5MT

It is an opinion thread, that is mine. I have a Toyota TRD/OR, newer type as my primary vehicle. I also had a nice Toyota HilUx mini truck I had owned for years and built up. I had to go to North Carolina on business for 3 months and took the HiLux. A lady ran a stop sign talking on the cell phone and totaled both vehicles. I needed a car, the Jeep dealership was right across from the accident scene. I walked over and drove out in a new WSO (Wrangler Shaped Object). Huge mistake, I realized about two miles down the road and vowed as soon as I could, I would dump it for a TJ, thank goodness, I finally found one I liked when I had some money and the mini van was paid for. :highfive:

J

wendell 06-23-2013 11:26 AM

The jk is an ugly beast that can scare the trails into submission. If you break a jk fender you can repair it with gorilla glue. A jk's bulky size can keep you out of trouble as you won't attempt anything too tight in the woods. A tj is a jeep while a jk is a baby hummer. If you buy a jk off of ebay your more likely to be out bid my a soccer mom than a hard core jeeper. Now for the good things about a jk......hum.....still thinking........................................st ill thinking...........O, they can be had in a pretty green he he.

dodgethejeep 06-23-2013 02:36 PM

You will miss the i6. Wish jeep had a v8 option for the jk. And every thing on the jk is computer controled. Can't just splice into a wire for some new acessory. I miss my tj, the wifes jk has more room than the tj ever had but its also a fat road hog because of it. Can't comment on the yj in comparison cuz i havn't got to play with it yet. Simple is good.

Habber 06-23-2013 03:20 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Ok. I was all ready to grab a JK that was all lifted and clean for 6k more than what I was about to sell my TJ for (2001 TJ vs a 2010 JK) but after reading all the negative comments about the JK, I think I'm going to miss the TJ, especially since its not my DD. it only has 115 KM (70k Miles) and I don't care about dents or DD cares. Looks like I might just keep it and build it up, especially since the add ons are a fraction of what JK mods would cost.

Attachment 640942

Jeep TJ 2001 4.0 5MT

takeitsleazy 06-23-2013 03:51 PM

Eh, I find a lot of TJ/YJ owners have an elitist attitude towards the JK. It is a great vehicle. But if you already have a TJ, I dont know why youd spend the money. Youre already having fun in a Jeep!

BYuen 06-23-2013 04:06 PM

If you have kids or need the extra space, a 4 door JK would be nice. Other than that, I wouldn't trade my TJ for a 2 door JK.

Renees05 06-23-2013 04:14 PM

Could always find a nice LJ. Keep the power and all the good TJ stuff! Also, you don't have to feel like a soccer mom with those extra doors!

jeepwrangler97 06-23-2013 04:15 PM

JK's have some benefits...I wouldn't want one though over a TJ

It's partially a personality thing...go drive one and see what you think. Personally, I think TJ's have a bit more charm and they feel more like you're in a Jeep.

Jk's are pretty quiet on the highway and are more car like...

I have had people ask me if I drive a "real Jeep" or a "new Jeep"...I don't hate on Jk's like some, but I still would take a YJ or TJ or LJ over one...Maybe I will want a 4 door when I'm old and have kids...but in addition to my TJ.

The 3.6L has power...but I love my straight 6 and not having an electronic throttle :cheers2:

I think it comes down to personality...JK's are cool..but I prefer TJ's...my buddy got a JK and loves it...

EDIT: I would rather be able to add an LJ into the mix before a 4 door if I could when I'm older

Grewe02 06-23-2013 04:19 PM

Pros of a JK over a TJ:
Swaybar disconnect.
Larger wheel wells.
Beefier stock suspension parts.

Pros of a TJ over a JK:
Everything else you can possibly think of, imagine, dream about, or theorize.



Not only that, but you can buy all of the afore-mentioned JK pros for a TJ from an aftermarket source.




Verdict: TJ wins.

Edit: Facebook brought me here

sxysouthtx 06-23-2013 04:59 PM

I used to have a TJ (which I miss) and drive a YJ now. But, my buddy had an 07' JK and it pretty good off road. However, everything about it was mini-vanish. The engine is more powerful and the D44 is standard in the rear, but I just can't stand them. You have to compete with every bro-dozer out there (4 door) on 35s that will never wheel the damn thing and look down on you. It looks like a barbie Jeep you get for your little girl when she is 3. The interior in very delicate. Now all of these issues wouldn't matter on any other vehicle. Be it a car, suv, truck. But this is a Jeep. I'll be damned to buy something and be stuck with the soccer moms, the bro's, and college girls. I think my YJ is ugly, but not nearly as ugly as a JK. Now that's not to say there aren't any awesome JKs. I've seen some that made my jaw drop. But at the end of the day, I can modify my YJ to tackle some nasty stuff much cheaper that a JK. So I vote TJ.


The time now is 01:39 PM.

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.