Hey guys, sorry if this isnt the right place but it's my first post.
I currently have a 2011 Liberty 4x4 and I'm trying to convince the wife to upgrade to a 2013 Wrangler Unlimited. I'm not worried about the price as I've gotten the payments comfortably to what we can afford, she's concerned about a few other issues.
1. She's concerned about the gas mileage. It has to be better than our Liberty as its a gas hog. The dealer assures me with the new engine it'll be better. The specs on the window of the Jeep suggest much better gas mileage than what I've been reading online. So my question is how much better mileage can I expect?
2. The only other thing is re-sale value. I think that a Liberty would depreciate faster than a Wrangler. 3-4 years from now what vehicle would give me the best value.
Thanks and sorry again if this isnt the right place. I've owned a few Jeeps but this would be my first new one and I want to get it right and not regret anything.
Well here is what the Feds say about your Liberty:
2011 Jeep Liberty 2WD 6 cyl, 3.7 L, Automatic 4-spd, Regular Gasoline
2011 Jeep Liberty 4WD 6 cyl, 3.7 L, Automatic 4-spd, Regular Gasoline
And basically here is what they say about the Wrangler:
So Gas mileage is most likely no difference, however resales value will blow the Liberty out of the water.
Practically speaking I'd say I generally get around 18mpgs in town, and 16 /17 on the highway. I generally use cruise control, and go around 75-80MPH. Based on resale value, the wrangler will hold its value far better. Demand is far higher , and if I had to guess, the demand for post 2012 wranglers is gonna go higher because people want the 3.6L over the 3.8L.
EDIT: As people have noted, you're going to get probably 20MPG's if you drive at 60 or 65 with the cruise on on the highway. The drop in mileage as you go up in speed is enourmous, until you consider that you're forcing a 4500lb brick through the air at 80MPH. I just like to drive fast
75-80mph will net you worse gas mileage than cruising at 65-70mph. So that is a variable that depends on the driver. Also, remember, if you start adding bumpers, rock rails, larger tires, and other heavy items, that will affect gas mileage too.
You should calculate the gas mileage your liberty gets by hand and then compare. I drive my 2dr manual with a heavier than normal foot and the cpu says i get about 20.8 miles to gallon but doing the math by hand i get roughly 17-18 mpg. That is also with about 50/50 highway city driving to and from work. Since you are looking at a 4dr, one of my friends drives a 4dr auto and he gets roughly 17-18 mpg which he calcualted out by hand. Only time I ever get 21 mpg on the highway is if i drive 65 mph.
Here is the truth - You are ready to sell the liberty. If you get a JKU then you will NEVER be ready to sell(unless you are upgrading to another JKU). Resale value is unbelievable on JKU's and like I said - Once you own one you will never want to let it go. Any other car, liberty, etc... who cares if you sell it and they are a dime a dozen...
My wife's '11 Liberty 4x4 and my '13 Rubi both get almost identical fuel economy. I hand-calculate mpg for every tank. We both drive conservatively. The Libby does do a little better than the JK on long trips. YMMV, but I think you would be disappointed if you make the decision based on fuel economy.
Our Liberty has the full time transfer case. My wife knows in winter wx & other low traction situations, she can flip the switch to auto 4x4 and drive. No worries if left in 4x4 on dry pavement. Not the same story with the JK.
One other thing to consider is difference in tow capacity between the two. The lib is rated a little better and does tow pretty well.
'14 WK2 Overland
'13 JKU Rubicon
Jeeps past 01 XJ, 08 JK, 11 KK
Honestly, I don't get more than 17-19 combined but, I trade my 13 sport to 13 rubicon. I made 300. It crazy that how much your wrangler will bring on the table when time trade than any other brands including great japanies cars. You may spend $30 more for gas a month but, you will get better return when you ready to trade.