FWIW, that's a BEAUTIFUL rig. I think you did ok. Not a steal, but not a rip off either. Jeeps require more maintenance than most vehicles, and ESPECIALLY if they're modded heavily like that one is. Drive it with a smile on your face!!
Black '05 LJ, soft top, ~4" lift, 42rle, 3.73, 35"x12.5" AT's, Tampa FL area