I debated long about whether to get black or shiny. I was set on shiny when ordering and changed my mind and went black. When they showed up and I first put them on my Jeep, I thought I had made a mistake and was thinking that the shiny was a better look. After a day I really warmed up to the black and think my Jeep looks much better with them. I think in either case your Jeep will look great though. Just don't get any wheels with some frilly styling.
1994 YJ Wrangler, 4.0, AX15, NP231, 35x12.50x15 BFG KM2s, 4" RC lift, 1" lift Boom Shackles, 1" BL, 4.10 gears, 8.8 LSD in rear and D30 Aussie Locker in front, on-board air conversion, Ramsey RE8000 winch.