I put Dayton Timberline ATs on my TJ at 122K. 33K later, they are wearing very well. I see another 15K in them at least. I have done a 5 tire rotation every 5K. I don't go offroad very often, so I can't comment on mud or rock performance. They have done fairly well on wet pavement, which is concern in FL. Next go around, I'm getting the BFG TAKOs, which I can get mounted and installed for $130 per tire, very close to what I paid for the Timberlines.
'97 TJ Sport, 4.0L, AX-15, D30/35, BFG TA KO 183K
'12 F30, '03 E46, '06 Rabbit, '13 Jetta