possibly 2 wires are shorted, thus grounding the switch causing the lights to stay on. im not 100% if the head lights are power or ground switched, but if they are ground side switched id check the wires
'96 ZJ Orvis 5.2L (Mossy Oak Edit.)- UC+2" BB, Thrush Turbo, 2 12s, Lots Of Stickers
You drive a tj, we drive a zj. We have more power while you get more shower. We get the v8 while you get there too late. You have 2 doors well, we have 2 more. Ours costs a grand while yours has a price we cant stand.