Semi gloss will look just as good.
Gloss will make the smallest imperfections stand out like a sore thumb. So, I would go with the semi gloss...
91' YJ,4.0 I-6(180,000 mi) 2" Rancho Add-A-Leaf kit, 1.5" shackle lift, 2" BL, 33x12.50 BFG M/T KM's, 15x8 589's, TJ flares, custom F&R bumpers w/ swing-away spare carrier & rocker guards, FULL ROLL CAGE, herculiner, Warn [B]XD9000i[/B] (IT'S ALSO MY WIFES... or was!!!)
Rig Rater score= 476RRv1.0
Its a dog-eat-dog world. and I'm wearing MILKBONE UNDERWEAR!!