I got a 3.5 inch BDS lift and it was really really tall (like maybe 4 or 5) my dad almost didn't let me drive it home. But it setteled down and now its around 3 or 3.5, 2 months later so i'd say give it some time if you can stand the vibrations.
Black 2012 JKUR 2.5" Rock Krawler Max Travel suspension with Bilstein 5100's, 35X12.5R15 MTRK's on MB Ultras, Sleeved and gusseted front axle with Synergy balljoints, JCR bumpers F/R
Old Jeep, SOLD:
94 Green YJ SE 4.0L 5spd
3.5" BDS lift, 1"MML/BL, Revolvers, SYE/CV, no track bars or sway bars, MORE sport cage
Green Jeep Club Member #20